Treasure Tier

GingerBraveGingerBraveTreasure Tier
The Sugar Gnome's Warehouse's official lineup of numerous Tresaures ranked by their perceived potential in multiple different game modes.
  • S+ Tier - a treasure that must be at the highest level
  • S Tier - a particular deck, a treasure used in a particular situation
  • A Tier - an unused treasure
  • B Tier - scarcely used treasure
  • $$ Tier - Only used for increasing the amount of Coins gained in battle, and do not improve Cookies in any way
TierTreasureEvaluation
S+Old Pilgrim's ScrollEPIC_treasureOld Pilgrim's Scroll* Essential Treasure, granting a powerful ATK boost to all Cookies on a team. * Giving a buff similar to a full 5x M Searing RaspberrySearing Raspberry set when maxed out, the increase in ATK can mean the difference between victory and defeat in almost any case, as almost every Cookie's Skill has an ATK scaling.
S+Squishy Jelly WatchCOMMON_treasureSquishy Jelly Watch* The easiest essential Treasure to max, being a Common Treasure * Cooldown reduction allows Cookies to use their Skills more often, rather than idly rely on their stats alone * Because even the charging cooldown of Skills is affected by Cooldown reduction, it's especially essential in Kingdom Arena, reducing the time before Cookies can cast their Skills at the start of the battle.
S+Sugar Swan's Shining FeatherEPIC_treasureSugar Swan's Shining Feather* Revives a single Cookie while resetting their Skill's cooldown * This only works once per battle, but can be a key asset in Kingdom Arena, bringing one's softest Cookie back with a ready-to-cast Skill.
S+The Order's Sacred ForkEPIC_treasureThe Order's Sacred Fork
S+Gatekeeper Ghost's HornCOMMON_treasureGatekeeper Ghost's Horn* Increases Cookie DEF, allowing them to survive more attacks. * It greatly improves the sturdiness of one's Front Cookies, while also keeping Middle and Rear Cookies from being too quickly defeated by stray shots and area-of-effect abilities.
SLibrarian's Enchanted RobesEPIC_treasureLibrarian's Enchanted Robes* Improves the ATK SPD of the two Cookies with the most bonus ATK SPD, has extremely effective utility in attack-speed compositions. * While it's recommended mostly for those specific compositions, it can nevertheless still help other progressing Cookie teams, and its buff targets can be easily selected via Toppings.
SBookseller's MonocleEPIC_treasureBookseller's Monocle* Help a Cookie team get through a level where enemies can inflict a potentially-lethal debuff on one's Cookie, or break them from a long stun, all the while healing the entire team. * Because of its lengthy cooldown, it's best to activate it when it can have the most effect. In Kingdom Arena, the cleanse and heal can turn the tide against an enemy Skill combo, or break them out of an area-of-effect stun to counterattack, although the very lengthy cooldown means that it can only happen once.
SPilgrim's SlingshotRARE_treasurePilgrim's Slingshot* Necessary for players against bosses such as the Red Velvet Dragon in Guild Battles, able to reduce a large percentage of the target's DEF for a short while * It also helps make backline enemies more susceptible to group damage, which could help defeat Rear position Cookies earlier in Kingdom Arena.
SBear Jelly's LollipopRARE_treasureBear Jelly's Lollipop* The most benefits Cookie teams progressing through World Exploration, as timing it with the strongest Cookie's Skill will deal great damage to any wave. * Because auto-battle uses it immediately cooldown, it's less reliable in Kingdom Arena, but it can also make a team's strongest Cookie even more dangerous in the first few seconds of a battle.
SGrim-looking ScytheRARE_treasureGrim-looking Scythe* Similar to Old Pilgrim's ScrollOld Pilgrim's ScrollOld Pilgrim's Scroll in that it can increase a Cookie team's damage output. * While it's not necessarily reliable in that regard since it increase CRIT chance rather than damage, combining it with the Old Pilgrim's ScrollOld Pilgrim's ScrollOld Pilgrim's Scroll can allow a team to "cheat" through fights with a greater chance of additional burst damage.
SSeamstress's Pin CushionEPIC_treasureSeamstress's Pin Cushion* Buffs both the ATK and duration of summoned creatures. Combined with the Old Pilgrim's ScrollOld Pilgrim's ScrollOld Pilgrim's Scroll, this Treasure can improve a summoned creature's Attack by over 60%, which can really boost the damage output of summoner Cookies. However, it goes without saying that only summoner Cookies make use of this Treasure.
SInsignia of the Indomitable KnightsEPIC_treasureInsignia of the Indomitable Knights* Mandatory for teams that use Tea Knight CookieTea Knight CookieTea Knight Cookie, healing all Cookies by a percentage of their max HP whenever an ally is defeated, while also granting the final survivor a short period of invincibility before they can be defeated themselves. * Tea Knight CookieTea Knight CookieTea Knight Cookie's Tea knight skill Battlemaster can be optimized using this treasure, allowing him to tear down almost any team by himself after his teammates fall. * Other teams can also use this treasure simply to counter one-shot compositions in Kingdom Arena, assuming they're tanky enough to counterattack. * However, it's far poorer for World Exploration, as it requires Cookies to fall to have any effect.
SDivine Honey Cream CrownEPIC_treasureDivine Honey Cream Crown
AMiraculous Natural RemedyEPIC_treasureMiraculous Natural Remedy* Very useful for teams that use Tea Knight CookieTea Knight CookieTea Knight Cookie, providing both heals and purifying effects exclusively to the Cookie with the highest Health. * This treasure can also be used in Story Mode if your team has only one tank, as it improves their survivability by targeting them exclusively.
ABlind Healer's StaffEPIC_treasureBlind Healer's Staff* Gives an additional means of healing, granting a heal-over-time on one's lowest Health Cookie. * It's not a substitute for a Healing Cookie, however, and doesn't always target the Cookie that the player needs healed first.
AEcho of the Hurricane's SongRARE_treasureEcho of the Hurricane's Song* A powerful one-hit treasure that can deal the most damage out of any other options, especially when combined with DEF reduction abilities. * However, it has a massive minute-long cooldown, and so typically does nothing else as soon as it's spent. * It's best used in battles expected to end quickly, such as in Tower of Sweet Chaos levels or alongside one-shot compositions.
AElder Pilgrim's TorchEPIC_treasureElder Pilgrim's Torch* Grants another means of inflicting additional damage, doing so in a small area. * This can be somewhat useful in clearing Stages faster if one lacks the damage, but relies on enemies being within the given area to have an effect. * It can be more effective in Kingdom Arena where Cookies may not move around as much, and can help a team win even when left with only a Healer Cookie.
ASacred Pomegranate BranchEPIC_treasureSacred Pomegranate Branch* Shields every Cookie on the team based on their Max HP. * It can help a team survive Kingdom Arena teams reliant on bursting the enemy in one Skill combo, but it isn't reliable in that regard, and has a long cooldown as well.
BDurianeer's Squeaky Flamingo TubeEPIC_treasureDurianeer's Squeaky Flamingo Tube* Increases the maximum HP of the two Cookies with the highest HP, allowing bulky Front Cookies to live even longer. * It can help when trying to 3-star World Exploration stages, but it doesn't improve a team's damage output, nor can it replace having adequate healing.
BPriestess Cookie's Paper CharmRARE_treasurePriestess Cookie's Paper Charm* Removes buffs and deals a percent of the team's total ATK. * In Kingdom Arena, it can help against buff-reliant compositions, but it otherwise doesn't help as much as other Treasures, dealing less damage than Elder Pilgrim's TorchElder Pilgrim's TorchElder Pilgrim's Torch. * Most enemies in World Exploration aren't reliant on buffs either.
BMiraculous Ghost Ice CreamRARE_treasureMiraculous Ghost Ice Cream* Reduces the armor of the nearest enemy, allowing Cookies to whittle down a frontline more quickly. * It can mildly substitute for the Treasure Pilgrim's SlingshotPilgrim's SlingshotPilgrim's Slingshot against bosses, although it inflicts less DEF Down, and is less reliable against bosses that can summon enemies.
BJelly Worm's Sticky GooEPIC_treasureJelly Worm's Sticky Goo* Briefly protect the most vulnerable Cookie. * While it could help that Cookie survive a lethal attack, its minute-long cooldown means that the Cookie team should be able to defeat their enemies before they can attack again.
$$Ginkgoblin's Trophy SafeCOMMON_treasureGinkgoblin's Trophy Safe
$$Cheesebird's Coin PurseCOMMON_treasureCheesebird's Coin Purse
working_gnome
Sugar Gnome is working hard!